Friday, December 17, 2021

Guerrilla skeptics as seen by the Wikipedia_POV wiki

 More of that raw Wikipedia_POV data goodness:

Guerrilla skeptics

From The Wikipedia POV
Jump to: navigation, search

The self-assigned name for a group of pro-science skeptics who are openly editing Wikipedia in a coordinated way. They attack psychics, quack medical practitioners, pseudoscience pushers, and related issues by editing Wikipedia articles using undeclared socks. For whatever reason, Rupert Sheldrake is a favored target. His BLP has become absurdly long and abusive for a semi-obscure figure.

Contents

[edit] past explosions

Mentioned in the following Wikipediocracy threads:

[edit] members

The principal member is Susan Gerbic, Sgerbic (T-C-F-R-B). Socks which appear to be directly involved include Barney_the_barney_barney (T-C-F-R-B), MrBill3 (T-C-F-R-B), Alfonzo Green (T-C-F-R-B), Joshuafilmer (T-C-F-R-B), Valis55 (T-C-F-R-B) and others. Many are members of Wikiproject Skepticism, a project with some rather questionable members. (See Joshua Schroeder, Tyciol, Noleander, Ellen Smith, Frank Bednarz, Sage Ross, William M. Connolley. Plus longtime players Aaron "VoiceOfAll" Schulz (currently a WMF software developer), "Loremaster" (see Transhumanism), "IRWolfie", Doug Weller, and WMUK pest Martin Poulter, many of whom are savage anti-Scientologists.)

Occasional rare spluttering about their activities has appeared on noticeboards.[1][2][3][4][5]

There was a 2011 Signpost article about Gerbic and company. "Despite assurances from Gerbic that "it's not vandalism, which it kinds of sounds like, because we are totally following the rules", concern has already been expressed that editors may attempt to give otherwise neutral articles a pro-skeptic slant. Although in the past there have been crackdowns on religious POV-pushing (most notably the Scientology arbitration case), Gerbic was clear that what has been left behind is not sufficiently pro-skeptic, describing the "skeptical content" on Wikipedia as "not very good". "

As mentioned on Wikipediocracy[6], it appears that "Barney the barney barney" has extremely close connections to retired British archaeologist, Francis Pryor, and has done almost obsessive glorification of Pryor, his family, his friends -- but has also participated heavily in the attacks on Sheldrake.

[edit] Tim Farley

One of the worst sock operators, and the principal attacker of Sheldrake, is Vzaak. He appeared on Wikipedia in July 2013 and did almost nothing but fight over the Sheldrake bio and that of Terence McKenna. Vzaak is suspected of being Tim Farley, a fire-breathing skeptic blogger whose Wikipedia bio was created by Susan Gerbic. Farley also operates Krelnik (T-C-F-R-B), his primary account. Another account dating from July 2013 and having a similar profile (fighting over the Sheldrake article and arguing on talkpages) is Manul (T-C-F-R-B).

Yes, he is openly using sockpuppets to editwar. And he has never been called to account for these sock accounts on any Wikipedia noticeboard. Although he is allowed to fight with administrators on noticeboards, there is no evidence of resulting restrictions. Vzaak made a terror of himself on arbitration enforcement areas. [7][8][9][10] And Vzaak is allowed to heap assorted evidence onto his enemies on Sockpuppet Investigations. He is a remarkably determined "Wikilawyer". [11][12]

Some time in 2015, all of Vzaak's contributions and logs mysteriously vanished. There is no visible evidence of an oversighter destroying his history -- most likely it was merged to the Manul account. It was obviously done to cover up Farley's years of abuses (however incompetently). This explanation seems likely, as Manul then replaced Vzaak on noticeboards and arbitration enforcement complaints. [13][14][15]

[edit] External items

The Skeptics group operate openly on blogs:




                     What Susan Gerbic looks like, doing her book jacket photo stance.


                         The living horror of Tim Farley/ Vzaak's visage.

Sunday, December 12, 2021

Adam Hyland ("Proton-k", allegedly.)

 Below is an example of what the Wikipedia_POV wiki looks like, at least in .pdf form.


Adam Hyland

From The Wikipedia POV
Jump to: navigation, search
Adamhyland.png

Contents

[edit] background

AKA Protonk (T-C-F-R-B) (supposedly pronounced proton - K). Evil edit-warrior, banned many people in disputes, seems to enjoy protecting their userpages. Lives in Chicago, former US Navy, recently graduated from economics school at University of Chicago. A regular Slashdot user. Basically a complete nobody--except on Wikipedia.

[edit] WP history

"One of the things you learn in anthropology is that if you see a seemingly bizarre cultural phenomenon then you really should be asking why that exists"

Oldest diff April 2008. Most of his article-writing has been about Navy subjects. He has been accused of plagiarizing an article, it may not be his only one. Although he started out as a gnome/contributor, he eventually became an extremely incivil and foul-mouthed deletionist and talkpage troll. Seems to enjoy the defamatory possibilities of WP BLPs.

RFA October 2008. Adam revealed that he had installed and used MediaWiki before coming to Wikipedia, thus explaining (to their satisfaction) why he showed up and promptly started voting on AFDs. This is likely to be a smokescreen, to cover up previous accounts.

There are few complaints in AN/I about him, this one is typical. He occasionally participates on SPI. Uses other admins for "cover" and is otherwise "sneaky", when he isn't directly abusing someone for a minor transgression. Tends to avoid Arbcom pages.

WR thread: [1]

Protonk was one of the administrators involved in the harassment of Clayton Olney, albeit unknowingly.

In 2014, after years of declining interest, Adam returned to "editing", which in his case consists mostly of deletions and voting. In August he was the administrator who killed off one of Wikipedia's most asinine "lists of" articles, "List of notable Ice Bucket Challenge participants". [2][3] As usual for current events, the primary article Ice Bucket Challenge was subjected to ugly editwars for weeks. It was created on 13 August by none other than Jinkinson (T-C-F-R-B) (see David Gorski).

In the midst of the Zoe Quinn/Gamergate argument on AN/I, Adam the "fucking loser" felt compelled to attack Gorski.

"It's an interesting moral quandary, isn't it? On the one hand, WP:OUTING is strongly forbidden by site policy, and it causes people significant distress. Some "outings" appear to have served no greater purpose than satisfying the sadism or vindictiveness of some obsessive grudge-bearer. On the other hand, Wikipediocracy contributors have also successfully identified several cases of serious abuse of Wikipedia, where repellent behavior would have continued indefinitely if not for Wikipediocracy's "outing" (the cases I have in mind are those of Qworty (talk · contribs) and Little green rosetta (talk · contribs), although the latter seems to be active again now with an alternate account). We actually owe Wikipediocracy a debt of gratitude for calling attention to those cases, because these "outings" served a constructive purpose and likely reduced the real-life harm these individuals had caused. So... like most real-life ethical questions, it's not as black-and-white as one would like to believe. MastCell Talk 17:17, 9 September 2014 (UTC)"
"As someone who got doxxed for "behaving badly" by having opinions about BLPs, you can fuck right off with that. The real world is the real world, but doxxing isn't some proportionate punishment meted out for sins, real or imagined. It's cowardly bullshit designed to chill speech and heap scorn on people from afar. Protonk (talk) 19:16, 9 September 2014 (UTC)"
"I'm not sure whether this is a response to me (based on the indenting, I'm guessing it's not), but in any case I'd put your "outing" firmly in the category of "served no greater purpose than satisfying the sadism or vindictiveness of some obsessive grudge-bearer." I'm sorry if I implied otherwise. MastCell Talk 19:42, 9 September 2014 (UTC)"
"It was not directed at you. I was torn between just indenting for threading or pinging, but I figured it was less justifiable to "ping" someone and tell them to fuck off than it would be to just say it. Protonk (talk) 19:49, 9 September 2014 (UTC)"
"To respond to your comments that it isn't always black and white, that is true but in a really unpelasant way. To the person doing the doxxing, it's often completely black and white. Back in the day BLP apostasy was exactly that in the eyes of folks at WR and other places. BLPs were a struggle for the heart of the project and represented a real potential damage to humans based on anonymous work. We can look at them and say that this manichean view was unfounded, but they don't feel that way. The folks at Wikipediocracy are likewise concerned over sexism and harassment getting "justified" in the encyclopedia. Their concern "looks" better to us (after all, the gamer gate stuff is disgusting, but that's a story for another time), so we might be more inclined to view the outing as a necessary journalistic evil. But I don't think we need to dig too far into the piece to see that characterization as strained. The run down on TD from that article is basically "look at this fucking loser", which is par for the course with outing articles. Protonk (talk) 19:58, 9 September 2014 (UTC) "

[edit] Identity

  • This page is linked from, and links to his Wikipedia page. He introduces himself at a boring Wikimedia conference here.

[edit] Gets blocked

He was blocked in January 2015 for some weird violation of Arbitration Enforcement - by none other than Harry Mitchell. For those with the appetite, the ANI discussion is here. It stemmed from some of Hyland's activities in the Zoe Quinn/Gamergate battle.

"I have a newfound appreciation for how byzantine our processes are for getting unblocked and how helpless a blocked editor can feel. That is all. Protonk (talk) 03:26, 30 January 2015 (UTC)"

[edit] Twitter escapades

In July 2016 he defends his friend Robert Fernandez by forcing Slate writer David Auerback off Twitter. [4] "Auerbach sent his media inquiries on Friday (and received no answer), and Fernandez went after him on Saturday, tweeting (and possibly calling and/or emailing) Slate and New America, two publications Auerbach has worked for."

By this time, Adam had successfully found himself a job -- with the Wiki Education Foundation. [5] Working for Frank Schulenburg, next to Sage Ross and Ian Ramjohn.

[edit] other

Saturday, November 27, 2021

What's Been Going on With Patriots.Win, aka "The_Donald Without Reddit"

 For those that follow Reddit (and why the Hell are you wasting your time doing that?) a couple of years ago they banned a wad of forums ("subreddits") that Reddit (and I know it's stylized "reddit", but screw Steve Huffman) found objection for a number of reasons, and this was a site that hosted r/nazi, r/coontown, and r/picsofdeadkids (all real and banned subreddits). The Chapo Trap House subreddit (which was not loved by the hosts of the podcast it was an alleged fansite of) vanished the same day as r/The_Donald, except the the Trumpist website had already fled to TheDonald.win, a freestanding subreddit built off the "top level domain" .win, which is for gambling websites and off-track betting. Because of the January 6th Capitol riot, they changed URLs to Patriots.win and they are operating there still. TheDonald.win became America.win, and it has the following message:



The author of that  was Jody Williams, an ex-US Army guy with a buzzcut who has been called a "traitor" by The_Donald faithful. He was co-ordinating with the redditors as far back as 2019; they knew they had been on thin ice since 2017, and they were looking for an escape route. Patriots.win is that escape.



Above: What the front page looked like on the morning of 11-27-21. Notice that the "top stories" are all designed to rile the intended audience.
Below: Trump "snark dancing" photo, screenshot taken March 5, 2022.


There are now sub-sites to the Patriots.Win main page. Here is their alleged comedy page (03-09-22):



There is a question as to how many of the old moderators of The_Donald are still involved with this "new" website. Below is a list of the moderator of Patriots.win from March 5, 2022.


And here is a copypaste of a list from 2018 made by the writer of The_Donald's moderators. All of the names in bold match the above list:

Mods as of 10-23-18:

shadowman3001 (523828) 1 year ago full permissions

US2A (336062) 1 year ago full permissions

sublimeinslime (312268) 1 year ago full permissions

zettapede (43723) 1 year ago access, config, flair, mail, posts, wiki

thunderbert80 (1883442) 1 year ago access, config, flair, mail, posts, wiki

Ivaginaryfriend (1655523) 1 year ago full permissions

mivvan (416777) 1 year ago access, flair, mail, posts, wiki

Katfish29 (106304) 1 year ago access, flair, mail, posts, wiki

lalicat (86252) 1 year ago access, config, flair, mail, posts, wiki

SportzStar (22529) 1 year ago access, flair, mail, posts, wiki

D4rkd3str0yer (125461) 1 year ago access, flair, mail, posts, wiki

Sanotsuto (7356) 1 year ago access, flair, mail, posts, wiki

bh506407 (47785) 1 year ago access, flair, mail, posts, wiki

pm_me_yo_doggos (63683) 1 year ago access, config, flair, mail, posts, wiki

CovfefeBucks (37436) 1 year ago access, flair, mail, posts, wiki

DrWeeGee (1755095) 1 year ago access, flair, mail, posts, wiki

DanWofSoc (438616) 1 year ago access, config, flair, mail, posts, wiki

BotForceOne (1) 1 year ago access, flair, posts, wiki

AutoModerator (1778) 1 year ago posts, wiki

joshhawley2018 (56243) 7 months ago access, flair, mail, posts, wiki

-F-B-I- (29664) 7 months ago access, flair, mail, posts, wiki

nimblecalifornian (18239) 7 months ago access, flair, mail, posts, wiki

pray_for_kekistan (129334) 7 months ago access, flair, mail, posts, wiki

Foss_is_Boss (155674) 4 months ago access, flair, mail, posts, wiki


That's four out of twenty-four that are a direct match from four years ago. Doggos and pm_me_yo_doggos are probably the same person, and I'm sure that a lot of the others are there as well. Two of the people on our 2018 list (joshhawley2018 and shadowman3001) were mentioned in a 2019 DailyDot article trying to replace the banned The_Donald subreddit with a formerly-private subreddit called Mr_Trump which had gone dormant. That subreddit was later banned, which meant that the users in question just joined TheDonald.win team if they weren't running it already.

Why should we care?

Well, a part of social media website became the public interface for a political campaign, and then the administration that followed it, a portion that because a hangout for the most radicalized members of a political party. The media claims that this portion of the social media website became the target for a Russian troll farm ahead of the election in 2016. Mother Jones ran an article in 2020 how the moderators of that portion gamed Reddit's rules and were able to stave off being banned for years. The story of The_Donald and Patriots.Win shows the power of the Internet, at least the propaganda/disinformation uses of it, which are frankly terrifying.





Tuesday, November 23, 2021

Non-Wikipedia: Thanksgiving TV Specials

The overlooked Fall holiday, Thanksgiving. Here is a collection of some of the lame nonsense they put on the televisual airwaves to celebrate this bit of Americana.



Garfield's Thanksgiving (1989). This appeared on CBS the same year the Saturday morning Garfield and Friends show premiered. Lorenzo Music was still voicing the title character, with Thom Huge continuing to voice Jon Arbuckle, Garfield's "owner." Gregg Berger, who had been voicing Odie the dog since 1984 (Garfield in the Rough, the "let's go camping" special), also voices him here. It says a lot that the Garfield Thanksgiving special came out after Halloween and Christmas.  



The Hoboken Chicken Emergency (1984). This is a VHS rip from a PBS tape, The Hoboken Chicken Emergency have never appeared on DVD or BluRay. Peter Billingsley from A Christmas Story (1983) plays Arthur Bobowicz, a kid sent out to get a Thanksgiving turkey in Hoboken, NJ. He comes back with a 266-pound (121 kg.) chicken named Henrietta. She escapes and hijinks ensue. Benny Baker, Hamiliton Camp, Dick van Patton, and Gabe Kaplan star in this 58 minute epic.



Like with It's the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown, you cannot watch A Charlie Brown Thanksgiving (1973) in any complete form on YouTube because the Schultz people went to Apple+. So there are bits and pieces left in Google's video wasteland.



Not really a Thanksgiving special but shot during the Bicentennial Thanksgiving of 1976 at Bill Grahan's Winterland Ballroom, The Last Waltz (1978) is The Band (Rick Danko, Garth Hudson, Richard Manuel, Robbie Robertson, and Levon Helm) giving their "final" performance with guests Van Morrison, Bob Dylan (ex-employer), Ronnie Hawkins (ex-employer), Joni Mitchell, Dr. John, Muddy Waters, Ringo Starr, Ronnie Wood, and many others. They gave the audience a turkey dinner and then the acts hit the stage. Martin Scorsese and Van Morrison were possibly coked out of their minds.


***

That's all I have for this holiday.

Happy Thanksgiving in spite of all of it.


Friday, November 12, 2021

Twitter Is a Sick Joke.

If you are naïve enough, you might think that Twitter, unlike en.Wikipedia is run decently. Wrong. Twitter is just like YouTube is run by 'bots and scripts so your comments now get yanked off YouTube if you stick in a URL to demonstrate a point. The social media sector of the Internet is extremely automated in 2021 (as it has been since at least 2010?) so if you cross an unwritten line at Beardo Jack Dorsey's shitheap, they lock your account.



Above, Exhibit A. Really watch from 4:46 to 14:21, which explains just how shitty Twitter is, how the site is no longer growing, how most people do not post their little thoughts, all the crappy ads, etc. The rest of the video (beond the "White nonsense" section) is an excruciating rundown of Ellis' worst tweets over the last decade or so and how the self-appointed Thought Police reacted. It should be understood that this material is collected at Kiwi Farms' board thread on Ellis where the gangstalkers of the site probably masturbate over the screenshots, because the userbase of that website are subhuman garbage who should be destroyed with flamethrowers like ice buildup on the eaves of an Arctic base.



Above, Exhibit B. The 'bots may be good enough now to recognize symbols and certain faces, and thus this photo might be considered "hate speech" in the updated terms-of-service. If you have a burner account, try to Tweet it and see what happens. Do Stalin or Pol Pot and see what happens as well. If you are a Twitter user, you are up against machines playing "buttinski", machines that are not intelligent as we know intelligence, yet trying to manage human affairs in an online space.



Above, Exhibit C. This is an example of the 'bots telling you that you tripped one of their stupid keywords. If you cross the line of the unwritten list of words, terms, or whatever, they zap you. You can waste two weeks trying to talk to an actual human, or take the punishment. This is how Twitter keeps the drama going. And yes, this person was nailed for using the term "cracker ass cracker", which should show how idiotic the 'bots are, they cannot distinguish comedy from dead seriousness.


Solution: Avoid Twitter if you can. We know very well that the number of actual posting users is far tinier than the idiots just watching these microposts sail past. It's not worth your time, even if you need some sort of Algonquin Round Table to spill jokes out at. The whole place is rigged to get your goat, and the number of soulless, heartless ecapees from Breibart or Prisonplanet is staggering. Just don't start.

"So why did you write this?" somebody will ask. Pretty much there has been little put online about Twitter the website itself. As with en.Wikipedia, the entire thing needs to be examined, both as a website and a social phenomenon, if not for the present, then at least for the future.


https://warfawhoseonfirst.ytmnd.com/

https://soundcollage3980khz.ytmnd.com


Wednesday, October 27, 2021

Not Even Wikipedia: Old Halloween Specials

 


Above: The Garfield Halloween special, which first aired on the CBS TV network in 1985. If you were of the right age, the world of analog TV seasonal "specials" was the norm. Because the IRC stuff annoys the readership, we've decided to go this route.



Halloween is Grinch Night (1977), a prequel to the 1966 special How the Grinch Stole Christmas. I think they used to run this one on NBC. This is a DePatie-Freeling production, which means it came out of the same studio as the animated Pink Panther film intros and the now long-forgotten Pink Panther and Inspector Clouseau cartoons.





Above: Witch's Night Out (1978), a Canadian-made special featuring the voices of Gilda Radner, Catherine O'Hara, Valri Bromfield, and Dan Aykroyd, so this is where Second City (SCTV) met Saturday Night Live. First ran on NBC in America, CBC in Canada; this writer saw it run on KTLA (Channel 5 in Los Angeles) as weekend filler between old monster movies in October. Is it ugly? Maybe. But it is the sequel to an earlier cartoon called The Gift of Winter (1974), with many of the same characters and Radner, Bromfield, Aykroyd voicing them. 





Top: NSFW warning, that is NOT It's the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown, it's mostoffensivevideos' re-edit and re-dubbing called It's the Great Dolemite, Charlie Brown. In that version all the kids are parodies of streetwise Black people, the dialogue is X-rated, and the runtime is down to 11 minutes or so. 

Middle and Bottom: You have to get the original 1966 special on DVD or off Apple+ the streaming service. These snippets of Great Pumpkin from YouTube predate that streaming service by a decade. Copyright is now elastic in the Internet age; only if an old media item is popular are they willing to defend it.


The Halloween That Almost Wasn't (1979); this recording was taken off WLS-TV in Chicago on the 28th of October the year the special premiered; includes all the obnoxious ads. Judd Hirsch as Dracula, Henry Gibson as Igor, Mariette Hartley as a witch; all involved in a plot to save Halloween from something trying to stop it, don't ask. This ran for years on the Disney Channel, was released on VHS under another title.




Above: The Worst Witch (1986). This is based on a series of kids books (1974-2018) written and illustrated by Jill Murphy and stars Tim Curry, Diana Rigg, and Fairuza Balk. Balk plays Mildred Hubble, a witch student at a witch boarding school, and she stinks at the magic bit. Accordig to IMDb the plot is this: "The headmistress of the school, Miss Cackle (Charlotte Rae), has an evil twin sister (Agatha) who plans to destroy the school. Can Mildred foil the plan before the Grand Wizard (Tim Curry) comes to the Academy for the Halloween celebration you'll never forget?" Tim Curry's aforementioned "Grand Wizard" (!) sings this crazy song when he flys in. This is a totally British production that originally ran on ITV in the UK before the Disney Channel picked it up and ran it on American cable for years.




Last but definitely not least, the Mystery Science Theater 3000 riffing of "Manos" - The Hands of Fate. Not really a Halloween special, but higher quality than most of the stuff I've linked here. Watch as a Texas family of three tries to take a vacation at a "Valley Lodge", gets lost and finds the house of "The Master" (Tom Netman) and his satyr manservant "Torgo" (John Reynolds), who both worship the unknown god Manos anlong with The Master's collection of wives. Are they zombies? A warlock and his familiars? The film never says. Made on a ranch outside El Paso, Texas and shot "wild track" (i.e., with no sychronized sound) on 16mm Bell & Howell home movie cameras, it's a very hand-made movie with loads of mistakes and thanks to using a restored version of the Ektachrome workprint, the visual element of this copy is fantastic when compared with the 35mm to Betamax dub Best Brains, Inc. used for the MST3K episode.

Here is Wikipedia's list of TV Halloween specials, so you can find more mind-rotting crap to look at this Halloween: link.









Friday, October 22, 2021

The Only Good Use for Zoom: Jimmy Wales, et. al, In a "Conversation" With the Wikimedia Foundation Board of Trustees; the Eostrix Story; Other Things

 As seen here beginning at 2:00 minutes in, Jimbo Wales speaking into a laptop camera. Also Rosie Stephenson-Goodnight with elves in the background of her audio. Is there any sincerety on display? I'll let the readers figure that out. Tip of the hat to the Gender Desk blog for pointing this video out....the video itself only has 345 views and is only two days old at this point, so as Eldon Stewart, Sr. always says on 75 meters -- "Nobody Cares!"



****

According to a member of the Wikipedia Sucks board, Wikipedia user Eostrix, who was up for ArbCom, turned out to be a sockpuppet of Icewhiz....according to Beeblebrox. Comments from the Brain Trust:

Original announcement
Request for Adminship suspended
  • Yikes. Thanks, ArbCom and/or CU team, for catching that in time. --Floquenbeam (talk) 01:10, 20 October 2021 (UTC)
  • That was... unexpected. Elli (talk | contribs) 01:11, 20 October 2021 (UTC)
  • What!? Moneytrees🏝️Talk/CCI guide 01:11, 20 October 2021 (UTC)
  • Unfortunate, but required. GoodDay (talk) 01:12, 20 October 2021 (UTC)
  • Icewhiz nearly became an admin? Wow. Pawnkingthree (talk) 01:19, 20 October 2021 (UTC)
  • !!! Twist of the year, for sure. JoelleJay (talk) 01:21, 20 October 2021 (UTC)
  • I feel very stupid supporting him. NW1223(Howl at me/My hunts) 01:24, 20 October 2021 (UTC)
    Don’t please, that was a real deep cover. - GizzyCatBella🍁 04:19, 20 October 2021 (UTC)
  • I am shocked and surprised. Thanks to the people who detected this. I thought that Eostrix was a good candidate and said so at length. I am also deeply disappointed. Cullen328 Let's discuss it 01:24, 20 October 2021 (UTC)
  • I realize this is fairly shocking. I can only assure you all that there is ample evidence, which we obviously cannot share as it is both private and would only provide Icewhiz with more information as to how we were able to make this determination. Our investigation was fairly involved, far beyond a usual checkuser investigation, and we did consult with some members of the CU team for second opinions before acting. This was a very determined, carefully planned attempt to fool the community, and it nearly succeeded, probably would have if it weren't for one particular committee member who doggedly pursued this for quite some time, although it obviously acquired a sense of urgency when the account ran for adminship. Beeblebrox (talk) 01:27, 20 October 2021 (UTC)
    @Beeblebrox Forgive me if this is too private for public discussion, but is there a need to contact T&S? NW1223(Howl at me/My hunts) 01:33, 20 October 2021 (UTC)
    The T&S team has been alerted by the Committee. Best, KevinL (aka L235 · t · c) 01:34, 20 October 2021 (UTC)
    Three members of the CU team evaluated the evidence and presented their thoughts. Of these, none were willing to give it a "confirmed" ruling, and two of the three emphasized that any potential block would have to be based on behaviour. – bradv🍁 03:19, 20 October 2021 (UTC)
    [This attempt to fool the community] nearly succeeded, probably would have if it weren't for one particular committee member who doggedly pursued this for quite some time, although it obviously acquired a sense of urgency when the account ran for adminship. I gather from this that some sockpuppetry evidence existed before the RfA, and was discussed privately within ArbCom for quite some time without being made public at SPI or elsewhere. It is proper for ArbCom to handle issues that cannot be described publicly, but I am wondering whether there is a "dark SPI" running in the background.
I suppose there is no way to show that the handling of the Eostrix case was justified without spilling much evidence. However I can ask the following question: how many cases of sockpuppetry based on private evidence, with a level of proof similar to pre-RfA Eostrix, are currently in the hands of ArbCom or its members, and how many are there typically at any given point in time? (An approximate number will suffice if the answer is above 5 or so). TigraanClick here for my talk page ("private" contact) 10:26, 20 October 2021 (UTC)
Given the comments that have been expressed above your message, I do not think it is realistic to expect the committee to say more than what they have chosen to say. I'm actually glad to see that the committee values privacy so highly, it prevents rumors from circulating. Once they are sure of the evidence, they act. Liz Read! Talk! 00:18, 21 October 2021 (UTC)
  • As a general note, I'd like to point out that there was no fault on the part of the nominators or the community. Without private evidence, there is just no way the community could have known. I very much appreciate that HJ Mitchell and GirthSummit put forth their talent as nominators. Neither the nominators or the community should beat themselves up for supporting. CaptainEek Edits Ho Cap'n!⚓ 01:31, 20 October 2021 (UTC)
+1 on that. Beeblebrox (talk) 03:02, 20 October 2021 (UTC)
+1 from me as well. {{u|Sdkb}} talk 08:56, 20 October 2021 (UTC)
  • While sad and shocking, I do have to commend ArbCom on acting as soon as they could. -- lomrjyo 🐱 (✉ • 📝) 01:46, 20 October 2021 (UTC)
  • Perhaps the saddest aspect is that this incident is likely to lead to increased skepticism and heightened scrutiny at RfA, which is aleady a grueling process. Cullen328 Let's discuss it 01:54, 20 October 2021 (UTC)
    Well said. I wish I had more to offer in response, besides to point out the ongoing brainstorming portion of WP:RFA2021. --BDD (talk) 02:03, 20 October 2021 (UTC)
    Does this tell us that our current scrutiny perhaps focuses on the wrong things? —Kusma (talk) 09:41, 20 October 2021 (UTC)
  • Wow. This is making me feel like my crazy suspicions aren't so crazy. Which is very sad. I'd really rather just be kind of crazy. —valereee (talk) 02:08, 20 October 2021 (UTC)
    And honestly, this right here is why working in SPI and the like gets downright exhausting: constantly wondering "is this new user too familiar with things? could this be (sockmaster) disguising themselves? am I just being paranoid/nuts?" GeneralNotability (talk) 15:06, 20 October 2021 (UTC)
  • This is crazy...gives me Archtransit vibes, but I'd never thought we'd nip it in the bud while the RFA was still going on! bibliomaniac15 02:36, 20 October 2021 (UTC)
    • I voted support for both Archtransit and Eostrix, and now seriously doubt my judgement ... -- Euryalus (talk) 03:31, 20 October 2021 (UTC)
      I am guessing this is tongue in cheek @Euryalus. But more seriously I do not think people should be analyzing every RfA candidate through the lens of "is this person an abusive sockmaster?" That is not the way to a healthier community in my opinion. Best, Barkeep49 (talk) 03:33, 20 October 2021 (UTC)
      @Barkeep49:Yes it is tongue in cheek. Fwiw Archtransit was in 2008 and of course Eostrix is today, so two similar cases in 13 years is not a bad record for en-WP. Hundreds of perfectly good RfA candidates have gone through over that time. So indeed, people should not let these two instances obstruct their usual approach to RfA . -- Euryalus (talk) 04:31, 20 October 2021 (UTC)
  • This is a shocker and I hadn't even cast a vote yet. I'm glad this came out before the RFA was closed successfully. I am used to reading about this kind of situation occurring 15 years ago but a sockpuppet getting this close to adminship in 2021 is a big surprise. Liz Read! Talk! 02:52, 20 October 2021 (UTC)


Icewhiz was banned in June, 2020.
 
****

We need more users of goodwill and not rubber-neckers from Wikipediocracy who won't comment. No more crazies please. Link to board.

****

Other stuff?

I lied.